Welcome
Tipping Encouraged
As business begins to stabilize, the staff and management have decided to return to a tipping encouraged policy with full table service. We have also returned to full occupancy with social distancing, enhanced cleaning, and facial coverings when possible.
Thank you for your support during these very challenging times and we look forward to serving the community for years to come. We remain grateful to serve you and the community and look forward to everyone enjoying our little piece of paradise.
Kind regards,
The Old Fish House Management.
Weekly Specials
Mon - One pound & 1/4 Jumbo Shrimp with Cheese Grits, Salad, & Hush Puppies - 20
Tues - Fish Fry w/ Fries, Slaw & Hush Puppies - 16
Wed - .79 Jumbo Wings
APPETIZERS
Jumbo Peel n’ Eat Shrimp HALF LB 12 / FULL LB 20
with Cocktail Sauce
Starter Wings Six 7.5 Ten 11
Traditional and boneless / Mild, Medium, Hot Teriyaki, Garlic, BBQ, Garlic Parm, or Spicy Honey Dry Rub: Old Bay or Jerk
Smoked Fish Dip 10
Smoked Local King Fish and/or Wahoo (as available) with Tortilla Chips
Calamari 12
Flash Fried with Chipolte Sauce
Conch Fritter 13
with Banana Peppers & Chipolte Sauce
Fire Roasted Mussels 12.5
Smoked Paprika, Olive Oil Served with Cuban Bread
Fried Green Tomato Stacks 9.5
Topped with Gorgonzola Cheese, Bacon & Balsamic Glaze
SOUPS
Black Bean Soup Cup 3 Bowl 5
with Sour Cream & Red Onions
Fish House Soup of the Day Cup 4 Bowl 6
SALAD
Fish House 14
Finished with Avocado, Almonds, Raisins, Bacon & Plantation Key Chicken
Lagoon 11
Finished with Almonds, Raisins, Bacon with Cheddar Cheese & Tomato
Add: Chicken 13 | Redfish 16 | Shrimp 15 | Steak 19 | Fresh Catch Mkt Price (Blackened, Grilled, or Fried)
1513 Salad 7
Tossed In Housemade Cuban Vinaigrette with Gorgonzola Cheese, Green Olives & Tomato
Add: Chicken 10 | Redfish 13 | Shrimp 12 | Steak 16 | Fresh Catch Mkt Price (Blackened, Grilled, or Fried)
TACOS
Grilled Flour Tortilla, House Made Pico De Gallo, Cotija Cheese & Fresh Guacamole Paired with Rice & Black Beans
Steak 12 Shrimp 12.5 Fresh Catch 13
Chicken 9 (Blackened, Grilled or Fried)
Gator 12 Redfish 12
BASKETS
Served with French Fries or Hush Puppies
Shrimp 11 Chicken Tenders 8 Gator 13
Redfish 11 Oyster 14 Fresh Catch Mkt
Wings 12.5
Traditional / Boneless - Mild, Medium, Hot Teriyaki, Garlic, BBQ, Garlic Parm, or Spicy Honey Dry Rub: Old Bay or Jerk
PO’ BOYS
Lettuce, Tomato & Pickle with Island Slaw, French Fries or Hush Puppies
Shrimp 12 Redfish 13
Chicken 11 (Blackened, Grilled or Fried)
Gator 13 Calamari 12 Oyster 15
BURGERS & SANDWICHES
On Request Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickle. Served with Fries or Island Slaw
Fish House Colossal Burger 13.5
Hand Pattied 10 oz Ground Chuck with Bacon & Cheese
Classic Burger 11
Hand Pattied 8 oz
Black & Blue Burger 12.5
Hand Pattied 8 oz Ground Chuck with Blue Cheese
Buffalo Chicken 12
Buttermilk Fried, Buffalo Tossed Topped with Blue Cheese
Fresh Catch mkt price
Blackened, Grilled, or Fried with House Made Dill Tarter Sauce
Ribeye Sandwich 15
Prepared To Your Liking 8 oz
Plantation Key Chicken 12
Fresh Grilled Pineapple Marinated Breast
Cubano 11
Mojo Pulled Pork, Ham, Swiss Cheese, Pickles & Mustard On Pressed Cuban Bread
Chicken Club 13
Marinated Grilled Chicken Breast topped with Bacon & Swiss Cheese
ENTREES
Served with Choice of Any Two Side
Sterling Silver Ribeye 27
Generously Marbled 14 oz
House Special Shrimp 20
Atop Rice with Black Beans, Grilled Tomatoes & Cotija Cheese
House Special Redfish 19
Atop Rice with Black Beans, Grilled Tomatoes & Cotija Cheese
House Special Ribeye 20
Atop Rice with Black Beans, Grilled Tomatoes & Cotija Cheese
House Special Chicken 13
Atop Rice with Black Beans, Grilled Tomatoes & Cotija Cheese
Butterfly Shrimp Platter 19
Blackened, Grilled or Fried with Cocktail Sauce
Oyster Platter 21
Flash Fried with Cocktail Sauce
Fisherman’s Platter 27
Fried Oysters, Shrimp & Catch (Blackened, Grilled or Fried)
Plantation Key Chicken 17
Pineapple Ginger Soy Marinated Breast, Rice, Grilled Fresh Pineapple
Chicken Tender 14
Buttermilk Fried with Honey Mustard
PASTA
Served with Lagoon Salad, 1513 Salad, or Vegetable
Chicken Cheese Tortellini 15
House Made Garlic Cream Sauce
Shrimp Cheese Tortellini 19
House Made Garlic Cream Sauce
Steak Cheese Tortellini 19
House Made Garlic Cream Sauce
Seafood Cheese Tortellini 21
House Made Garlic Cream Sauce
SIDES
Hush Puppies 2.5
French Fries 2.5
Sliced Tomato 2
Rice & Beans 3.5
Veggies 3.5
Red Potatoes 3
Island Slaw 2.5
Green Tomatoes 3.5
Plantains 3
1513 Salad 4
Lagoon Side Salad 4
DESSERTS
Key Lime Pie 4.5 Guava Cheesecake 4.5
KIDS
(for guests 12 years & younger) Served with Choice Of French Fries, Hush Puppies , Or Coleslaw
Corndog 5 Hamburger 6
Chicken Tenders 6 Kids Fish 6
Shrimp 6 Quesadillas 6
We Deliver
*CONSUMING RAW OR UNDER COOKED MEATS, POULTRY, SEAFOOD, SHELLFISH OR EGGS MAY INCREASE YOUR RISK OF FOOD BORNE ILLNESS, ESPECIALLY IF YOU HAVE AN EXISTING MEDICAL CONDITION
**PEANUTS, NUTS AND OTHER FOOD ALLERGENS ARE PRESENT. WE CANNOT GUARANTEE THAT OTHER PRODUCTS WILL BE FREE OF THE EIGHT MAJOR ALLERGENS IDENTIFIED BY THE FDA.